Frequently Asked Questions
The questions we hear most at the counter. Tap a question to see the answer. Do not see yours? Call us at (309) 797-5066.
Selling to us
What do I need to bring when I sell?
A valid, non-expired, government-issued photo ID. We will not buy without one. Sellers must be 18 or older; we do not buy from minors.
Bring your coins exactly as you found them, in whatever holders or albums they are in now.
I live out of state. Can I still sell to you?
Yes, as long as you have a valid, non-expired, government-issued photo ID from your state.
Do I need an appointment?
No. Come in any time we are open. Small batches never need an appointment. If you have what you consider a large collection, it is best to call (309) 797-5066 first.
Do you charge to look at my coins?
No. There is no charge to look at your coins.
How will I be paid?
Small transactions are paid in cash. Large transactions are paid by check.
How do you decide what to offer?
Silver and gold are bought from the current market price on the day you sell. Collectible coins are priced from what identical coins in the same condition have actually sold for, not from asking prices online. We trade with dealers across the country, so our offers are backed by the real market.
We explain what we are looking at and how we arrive at an offer. If something is not worth much, we will tell you so, and if it is something special, we will tell you that too.
The price guide says my coin is worth more. Why is the offer lower?
Most published price guides, including PCGS CoinFacts, show retail values for coins that have been professionally graded and certified. A coin that has not been graded, or that grades lower than expected, is worth less, and like any business, a dealer has to buy below retail. See A word about price guides.
Should I clean my coins before I bring them in?
No. Cleaning removes a coin's original surface and leaves fine scratches that cannot be undone. Cleaned coins sell for far less, sometimes a lot less. Bring them in exactly as you found them.
How do I know if you buy my coin before I make the trip?
Check What We Buy. It is the same list we hand to customers at the counter. Then check the free PCGS CoinFacts app: if your coin is not listed there, we most likely will not purchase it. Still not sure? Call (309) 797-5066 and we will tell you.
I inherited a collection. Where do I start?
Many of the people who walk through our door have just inherited a collection, so you are in good company. Do not clean anything, and do not take coins out of their holders or albums. Bring the collection in as it is, and we will explain what you have and what it is worth, in plain language. If the collection is large, please call first.
Will you come to my home to look at a collection?
Rarely. For a large estate that is being sold, we may be able to come to you. We do not make visits just to give an evaluation.
Do you do appraisals for insurance or an estate?
No. We no longer do formal insurance or estate appraisals.
Do you buy foreign coins and paper money?
We buy some modern foreign money that can still be exchanged, and some older foreign silver coins. We do not deal in rare or collectible (numismatic) foreign coins.
Do you buy scrap gold and sterling silver?
Yes. We buy scrap gold in any identifiable form, such as jewelry. We do not buy home-melted lumps. We also buy sterling silver flatware and sterling coins.
Should I send my coins to PCGS or NGC first?
You can if you want to. PCGS and NGC each have their own collector club, and you can submit coins to them directly, without going through a dealer.
Error coins and varieties
Do you buy error coins?
Most coin shops, including ours, do not buy modern errors or varieties. The market for them is small, and most are worth little or nothing to a dealer. We buy only the specific varieties listed on What We Buy, including the mainstream doubled dies listed by PCGS.
My coin looks doubled. Is it a doubled die?
Probably not. Most doubled-looking coins show machine doubling, which is very common and adds no value. A true doubled die has a rounded, fully detailed second image. See Doubled Dies Explained for how to tell the difference.
I saw my coin online for thousands of dollars. Is mine worth that?
Anyone can list a coin at any price. An asking price is not a sale. What matters is what identical coins in the same condition have actually sold for, which you can look up in the auction archives.
Is my 1943 penny copper?
Almost certainly not. Nearly all 1943 cents are steel. Quick check: a steel cent sticks to a magnet, and a copper one does not. Most "copper 1943" cents are steel cents that have been copper-plated, or 1948 cents with the 8 altered to look like a 3.
My coin has no mint mark. Is that an error?
Usually not. For most of its history, the Philadelphia Mint did not put a mint mark on its coins. Lincoln cents from Philadelphia carry no mint mark at all, except in 2017.
Silver and gold
Which U.S. coins are silver?
Dimes, quarters and half dollars dated 1964 and earlier are 90% silver. Kennedy half dollars from 1965 to 1970 are 40% silver. The 1942 to 1945 "War" nickels with the large mint mark above the building are 35% silver. Cents were never made of silver, and from 1965 on, dimes and quarters contain none.
Are dollar coins and Bicentennial quarters rare?
No. Susan B. Anthony dollars, Sacagawea dollars and 1776-1976 Bicentennial quarters were made by the hundreds of millions or more. Apart from the specific varieties on our buying list, they are worth face value.
Where can I check today's gold and silver prices?
The spot prices on our home page update during business hours. For live prices, we use and recommend Kitco. For our buying and selling prices today, call (309) 797-5066.
Buying from us
How can I pay?
We accept cash, personal checks, bank checks, cashier's checks and cards.
- Personal checks: bullion is held until the check clears.
- Cards: all card payments carry a 3% convenience fee, paid directly to the card processor. We do not receive it.
Do you charge sales tax?
There is no sales tax on coins or bullion. Sales tax applies only to supplies.
Do you take phone orders and ship?
Yes. We are a busy shop, so shipping sometimes takes a few days. If your order is time sensitive, please allow extra time.
Can you hold a coin for me, or do you offer layaway?
We do not hold items, but we offer layaway on items that are not bullion. Bullion is cash and carry.
Can you find a coin you do not have in the case?
Often, yes. Tell us the coin, the date and the grade you are after. If it is not in the case today, we can often find it through our dealer network.
How do I know a certified coin is genuine?
Our certified coins are graded and sealed by PCGS and NGC. Every one can be checked on the grading service's website by the certification number on the label. Links are on our Resources page.
Do you have gifts for a new collector?
Yes. Proof sets, Uncirculated Sets (Mint Sets), silver coins and starter coins all make good gifts for birthdays, graduations or a grandchild's first collection. Tell us the occasion and the budget, and we will help you pick something they will keep. See What We Sell.
Visiting the shop
What are your hours?
Monday to Friday, 10 a.m. to 5:30 p.m. Saturday, 10 a.m. to 3 p.m. Closed Sunday. We are a small, family-owned shop, and hours can change depending on staffing, so please call (309) 797-5066 before making a long drive.
Which holidays are you closed?
New Year's Day, Memorial Day, the Fourth of July, Labor Day, Thanksgiving and Christmas Day. We are open the day after Thanksgiving. On Christmas Eve, we may close early depending on customer traffic, so please call ahead.
What if the weather is bad?
If we close or change our hours because of weather, a notice appears at the top of every page on this website. When in doubt, call before you come in.
Where are you located?
3319 Avenue of the Cities, Moline, Illinois 61265. We have been at this location since 1999. Get directions.